
If the judges aren’t trying to get rid of Casey, then tell us why they gave him a John Mayer song. And not just any song, but the most boring John Mayer song ever. And that’s really saying something.
And if the judges aren’t trying to make sure Lee wins the season, then explain why Simon got to choose his song, coordinate the arrangement, dress him like a preacher man, give him halo-esque backlighting and a heavenly choir! Huh? Explain that, America!
Natalie was NOT happy. Take a listen.
The good: 5.19.10.1.American Idol Top 3 Best
The bad and the ugly: 5.19.10.2.American Idol Top 3 Worst